| Year |
Male |
Female |
| 2024 |
Spyros Chakas, Volleyball |
Olivia Davies, Basketball
Kaylee Glaugau, Beach Volleyball |
| 2023 |
Jakob Thelle, Volleyball |
Emma van Rossum, Water Polo |
| 2022 |
Andre Ilagan, Tennis |
Amy Atwell, Basketball |
| 2021 |
Rado Parapunov, Volleyball |
Hannah Gaskins, Track & Field |
| 2020 |
Colton Cowell, Volleyball |
Petra Melounova, Tennis |
| 2019 |
Stijn van Tilburg, Volleyball |
Raisa Strom-Okimoto, Soccer |
| 2018 |
Johnny Weeks, Baseball |
Franziska Weidner, Swimming |
| 2017 |
Kupono Fey, Volleyball |
Cole Brauer, Sailing |
| 2016 |
Kacy Johnson, Swimming |
Katie Spieler, Beach Volleyball |
| 2015 |
Taylor Averill, Volleyball |
Genevieve Bradley, Diving
Shawna-Lei Kuehu, Basketball |
| 2014 |
Davis Rozitis, Basketball |
Emily Hartong, Volleyball |
| 2013 |
Pi'ikea Kitamura, Baseball |
Kelly Majam-Elms, Softball
Stephanie Ricketts, Basketball/Softball |
| 2012 |
Matt Sisto, Baseball |
Kanani Danielson, Volleyball |
| 2011 |
Kealoha Pilares, Football |
Emma Friesen, Swimming |
| 2010 |
Andreas "Andy" Weber, Tennis |
Aneli Cubi-Otineru, Volleyball |
| 2009 |
Solomon Elimimian, Football |
Annett Wichmann, Track & Field |
| 2008 |
Colt Brennan, Football |
Kate Robinson, Softball |
| 2007 |
Mark Rodrigues, Baseball |
Kanoe Kamana'o, Volleyball
Brittany Grice, Basketball |
| 2006 |
Alfred Reft, Volleyball |
Allie Rowe, Golf |
| 2005 |
Chad Owens, Football |
Jennifer Warnock, Sailing |
| 2004 |
Michael Kuebler, Basketball |
Melissa Villaroman, Volleyball |
| 2003 |
Costas Theocharidis, Volleyball |
Kate Judd, Softball |
| 2002 |
Predrag Savovic, Basketball |
Molly O'Bryan, Sailing |
| 2001 |
Nerijus Puida, Basketball |
Andrea Nishioka, Water Polo |
| 2000 |
Dan Robinson, Football |
Raylene Howard, Basketball |
| 1999 |
Michael Dartt, Baseball |
B.J. Itoman, Basketball |
| 1998 |
Naveh Milo, Volleyball |
Nani Cockett, Basketball |
| 1997 |
Carlton Oswalt, Football |
Angelica Ljungquist, Volleyball |
| 1996 |
Clint Kuboyama, Football |
Tania Brunton, Basketball |
| 1995 |
Jason Olive, Volleyball |
Brandi Brooks, Volleyball |
| 1994 |
Jarinn Akana, Basketball |
Melanie Azama, Basketball |
| 1993 |
Travis Sims, Football |
Daniele Haia, Softball |
| 1992 |
Shawn Ching, Football |
Heidi McElhanney, Swimming |
| 1991 |
Dane McArthur, Football |
Patti Su'a, Softball |
| 1990 |
Jeff Ball, Baseball |
Judy Mosley, Basketball |
| 1989 |
Amosa Amosa, Football |
Sandra Budd, Swimming |
| 1988 |
Guy Farrow, Swimming |
Reydan "Tita" Ahuna, Volleyball |
| 1987 |
None |
Susan McDaniel, Diving |
| 1986 |
Michael Beazley, Football |
Susan Hlavenka, Volleyball |
| 1985 |
Joe Lileikis, Swimming |
Andrea Hawcridge, Swimming |
| 1984 |
None |
Rose Thomas, Tennis |
| 1983 |
Larry Goeas, Football |
Joy Minaai, Tennis |
| 1982 |
Brandon Kop, Golf |
Gillian Cooper, Tennis |
| 1981 |
Blane Gaison, Football |
None |
| 1980 |
Dean Dunn-Rankin, Tennis |
Bonnie Gouveia, Volleyball |
| 1979 |
Ron Nomura, Baseball |
Jane Zukaitis, Tennis |
