Fresno State scored the game’s first touchdown, but Hawai‘i answered back with three of its own. The Warrior defense helped set up all three scores by recovering Bulldog fumbles. Hawai‘i defensive back Dee Miller set a school record with three fumble recoveries. His two recoveries in the first half set up both of Hawai‘i's touchdowns. Dan Robinson's five-yard touchdown strike to Dwight Carter tied the game after the first quarter and capped a 52-yard drive. A 44-yard drive ended with Robinson's quarterback-keeper from the one-yard line. That score put the home team ahead at the half 13-7 after the PAT failed.
With a scoreless third quarter coming to a close, Hawai‘i linebacker Yaphet Warren recovered a Bulldog fumble. A short while later Robinson found Ashley Lelie from 15-yards out for a touchdown. Avion Weaver's run up the middle on the two-point conversion put Hawai‘i ahead 21-7.
Then the Bulldogs bit back. Fresno State scored two fourth quarter touchdowns to force overtime. An Aloha Stadium crowd of nearly 38,000, that had been singing in the stands anticipating the impossible, was reduced to stunned silence. Had Hawai‘i's version of "Mission Impossible" come to an end?
Hawai‘i won the overtime coin toss and elected to play defense first. In the first overtime, both teams traded field goals. Hawai‘i appeared to be on the verge of winning the game in the first extra period when they had a first-and-goal on the three-yard line. However, the Warriors were unable to get the winning six points and turned to place-kicker Eric Hannum, who had missed three of his last four attempts, to tie the game. Brian Smith snapped the ball to punter Chad Shrout who placed it nicely for Hannum. And then, while everyone in the entire stadium held their breath, Hannum's kick sailed 29-yards through the uprights and the Warriors were back in business.
In the second overtime, Hawai‘i started on offense. Robinson connected on a crossing pattern to Lelie for a 20-yard gain. Two plays later Robinson lofted the ball into the corner of the end zone and Stutzmann grabbed what would prove to be the winning touchdown.
"We knew we just had to get in there and score and put points on the board, not just three (points) if we wanted to win," said Stutzmann.
"I didn't think Dan (Robinson) was going to throw it to me, but right when it was in the air, I ran as hard as I could and secured it with all my might ... my little baby, that's what it was."
The Bulldogs still had an opportunity to force a third overtime, but thanks in large to the inspired play of defensive end Joe Correia, Fresno State would be denied. Correia, who was playing with one good hand and on one good knee, was good-to-go in the overtime period as he batted down one pass and sacked Bulldog quarterback Billy Volek. Volek's desperation pass on fourth-and-game sailed out of the end zone as the Hawai‘i football team sailed on to the field for a celebration to remember.